A federal permitting bill that would narrow the historic review behind some of Charleston’s biggest public projects moved closer to a final Senate vote on Wednesday.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act is a broad package meant to speed construction of energy and infrastructure projects. Its Title III would change the National Historic Preservation Act of 1966, including the Section 106 review process, Live 5 News reported Nov. 18.
Section 106 requires federal agencies to consider the effects of projects they carry out, approve or fund on historic properties, according to the Advisory Council on Historic Preservation, the federal agency that oversees the process.
Charleston’s preservation groups oppose the changes. The Charleston Metro Chamber of Commerce supports the push for faster permits.
Where the bill stands
The vote tallies Live 5 reported match Senate roll calls on a substitute amendment from Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, R-W.Va., to an unrelated House bill, H.R. 2347.
On Nov. 18, senators voted 70-26 to waive budget rules, 69-27 to adopt Capito’s substitute amendment, then 65-31 to cut off debate on the bill, the records show. Live 5 described the first vote as adopting a revised version of the bill and the second as moving it closer to a final vote.
South Carolina Sens. Lindsey Graham and Tim Scott voted yes all three times, as they did on earlier procedural votes Nov. 9, Nov. 10 and Nov. 16, Senate records show. As of Thursday night, the Senate’s roll call list showed no vote on final passage.
Sen. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., has proposed an amendment to strip Title III and keep the existing Section 106 framework, Live 5 reported. So far the amendment has only Democratic support, the station said.
President Donald Trump supports the reforms, The Post and Courier reported Nov. 15. The bill’s fate in the House is less clear, and Congress has until the end of the year to send it to the president before newly elected Democratic majorities are sworn in, the paper said.
Neither Graham’s nor Scott’s office had responded to Live 5 as of its report. A spokesperson for Scott declined to comment to The Post and Courier.
What would change
Under the proposal, fewer projects would be subject to review, effects would be evaluated differently, deadlines would be set, and consultation with state and tribal historic preservation officials would be limited, Live 5 reported.
Beveridge & Diamond, an environmental law firm, wrote in an Oct. 2 analysis that the bill as introduced Sept. 30 would write into law several definitions and processes now found in the advisory council’s regulations. The firm said it would generally leave indirect effects out of the review, shorten the process, and make it easier for an agency to end consultation without an agreement on resolving harm to historic properties.
The National Trust for Historic Preservation said Nov. 8 that it remains strongly opposed to the preservation title after a manager’s amendment, which it said would still exclude nearly all projects that receive federal financial assistance from review.
The business case
The Charleston Metro Chamber, which says it has about 1,600 members, backs the reforms. In a release quoted by The Post and Courier, it said growth is driving demand for reliable energy, “attainable housing and transportation infrastructure.”
The chamber said projects essential to meeting those needs “can spend years navigating federal reviews, approvals and litigation” before construction starts, the paper reported.
Section 106 in the Charleston area
The Post and Courier named the Battery sea wall, the James Island connector, the widening of S.C. Highway 41 through the Phillips community, a federal courthouse annex at the Four Corners of Law in the 1980s and the raising of the H.L. Hunley submarine in 2000 among projects shaped by the review.
Historic Charleston Foundation has written that the review led the James Island connector to meet Calhoun Street rather than Broad Street, and that the General Services Administration changed the courthouse annex’s location and design. The foundation also said the Battery extension design shifted from a T-wall to a linear park that still addresses flooding.
Lisa Jones, director of advocacy for Historic Charleston Foundation, told Live 5: “It gives complete power to the federal government to come ram a project down a community’s throat.” She urged residents to contact South Carolina’s senators in support of Schiff’s amendment, the station reported.
Brian Turner, president and CEO of the Preservation Society of Charleston, told Live 5 that outcomes have improved because local consultation has been part of the process, and that Title III is “far overbroad.” He warned that if the Army Corps of Engineers is no longer responsible for an aesthetically appropriate design of the Battery sea wall, Charleston taxpayers and city government would be on the hook for it, the station reported.
“Historic preservation is not and should not be a partisan issue,” Turner said.
Grant Gilmore, who directs the College of Charleston’s historic preservation and community planning program, told Live 5 the changes could lead to lawsuits. “That compromise process is being removed,” he said.
What’s at stake
The bill is not the only proposed change. Historic Charleston Foundation warned in August that the advisory council had voted July 24 to advance a draft revision of its Section 106 rules, which the foundation said would weaken local input.
For Charleston developers, utilities and public agencies that rely on federal money or permits, the outcome will shape how long reviews take and who gets a say before work begins.



