A state judge has ruled against a Mount Pleasant man who accused the S.C. State Ports Authority board of violating South Carolina’s Freedom of Information Act when it met behind closed doors shortly before CEO Barbara Melvin resigned in 2025, The Post and Courier reported Nov. 13.
Frank Heindel, a longtime government-transparency advocate who represented himself, sued Aug. 17. He argued the board should have told the public it would take up a personnel matter in the unscheduled closed session at its Aug. 19, 2025, meeting, the newspaper reported.
That hour-long discussion was later found to be about Melvin, who resigned from her $585,000-a-year job two days later. Her severance package totaled about $923,000, according to the paper.
Circuit Court Judge Dale Van Slambrook ruled only on whether the board privately voted on or committed to Melvin’s pay package. “There is no evidence that establishes the board took any impermissible action … including approving the … separation agreement,” he wrote Nov. 9, according to The Post and Courier. He said that finding settled the whole case.
Heindel said he won’t appeal. But he said the order skipped his main argument.
“Under South Carolina law, before a board goes into executive session it must announce the specific purpose, so the public understands why its business is being discussed outside public view,” Heindel said in an email, the paper reported. “The order never addresses that, which is what I argued.”
At an Oct. 20 hearing, port attorney Josh Whitley said the port “disputes anything unlawful occurred in this matter,” while acknowledging “there’s room for improvement” in how specifically the agency describes what it discusses, according to the newspaper.
The agency had no comment on the ruling, a spokesperson told The Post and Courier. Micah Mallace now leads SC Ports as president and CEO.



